A Model of the Multi-layered Good Governance System in Alavi Thought: A Thematic Analysis of Letter 53 of *Nahj al-Balagha* and a Comparative Analysis with Good Governance Indicators.

Document Type : .

Authors

1 shahed university

2 maaref uni

10.30465/alavi.2026.56050.2893
Abstract
However, these indicators are mainly based on secular philosophical foundations and have paid less attention to Islamic sources. This research aims to extract a model of good governance from letter 53 of Nahj al-Balagha (the testament of Malik al-Ashtar) and to compare it with indicators of good governance in Western models. The research has been conducted with a qualitative approach and thematic analysis method using the six-stage model of Brown and Clark (2006) to reveal points of commonality and difference. The results of thematic analysis of letter 53 led to the identification of 135 primary concepts, 18 basic themes, 7 organizing themes, and 3 overarching themes, which indicate the existence of a hierarchical and coherent structure in the Alawi governance model. This model is organized into three levels: comprehensive themes (based on monotheistic and ethical principles), organizing themes (including executive principles such as justice-centeredness and trustworthiness), and basic themes (operational concepts such as transparency and consultation). This structure establishes the link between "why" (fundamentals), "what" (principles), and "how" (methods) in the governance system. The comparative analysis showed that the Alawi governance model, while covering the indicators of Western good governance, has fundamental differences in monotheistic foundations, heretical goals, and the mechanism of divine supervision. The most important specific indicators of Alawi governance include divine supervision, belief in the afterlife, asceticism of rulers, and distributive justice beyond equality, which were presented in a comparative table at the end.

Keywords

Subjects